The basic characteristics of differential pressure signals and the limitation of flow rate metering methods based on differential pressure are studied analytically and experimentally. Through the investigation into differential pressure signals of orifice plate and V-cone, it is found that the two-phase differential pressure is mainly caused by gas phase and is slightly affected by the liquid phase. In the case of low liquid hold up, the frictional pressure drop can be decreased due to the presence of the thin liquid film on the wall, resulting in that the two-phase differential pressure, pressure loss and pressure loss ratio decrease at first and then increase as the liquid hold up increases. The fluctuation of the differential pressure is stochastic, causing the fluctuation characteristic parameters, such as the standard deviation, having the properties of poor stability and repeatability. This makes it difficult to be applied to industrial wet gas metering. The error propagation analysis demonstrates that the prediction error of liquid phase flow rate is much larger than that of the gas phase, which is a universal phenomenon of metering methods based on over-reading correlations. Finally, we recommend that for wet gas with high gas void fraction, the liquid flow rate should be measured independently. The non-monotonicity of the pressure loss ratio needs to be concerned if it is chosen as the characteristic parameter. Parameters with poor repeatability, such as standard deviation, are not recommended for wet gas metering.
[1] ASME. Wet gas flowmetering guideline,MFC-19G-2008[R]. New York,USA:The American Society of Mechanical Engineers,2008.
[2] MURDOCK J W. Two-phase flow measurements with orifices[J]. Journal of Basic Engineering,1962,84(4):419-433.
[3] LI Yuxing,WANG Jun,GENG Yanfeng. Study on wet gas online flow rate measurement based on dual slotted orifice plate[J]. Flow Measurement and Instrumentation,2009,20(4-5):168-73.
[4] ZHANG Fusheng,DONG Feng,TAN Chao. High GVF and low pressure gas-liquid two-phase flow measurement based on dual-cone flowmeter[J]. Flow Measurement and Instrumentation,2010,21(3):410-417.
[5] XU Ying,YUAN Chao,LONG Zhenghai,et al. Research the wet gas flow measurement based on dual-throttle device[J]. Flow Measurement and Instrumentation,2013,34:68-75.
[6] 贺登辉,张锋,曹洪贵,等. 基于单V锥节流装置的湿气气液流量在线测量[J]. 机械工程学报,2016,52(8):191-197. HE Denghui,ZHANG Feng,CAO Honggui,et al. Online measurement of gas and liquid flow rate in wet gas base on single V-cone throttle[J]. Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2016,52(8):191-197.
[7] MONNI G,de SALVE M,PANELLA B. Two-phase flow measurements at high void fraction by a Venturi meter[J]. Progress in Nuclear Energy,2014,77:167-175.
[8] HE Denghui,BAI Bofeng,ZHANG Jun,et al. Online measurement of gas and liquid flow rate in wet gas through one V-cone throttle device[J]. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,2016,75:129-136.
[9] 郭烈锦. 两相与多相流动力学[M]. 西安:西安交通大学出版社,2002. GUO Liejin. Dynamics of two-phase and multi-phase flow[M]. Xi'an:Xi'an Jiaotong University Press,2002.
[10] 白博峰,郭烈锦,陈学俊. 空气-水两相流压差波动研究[J]. 中国电机工程学报,2002,22(3):23-27. BAI Bofeng,GUO Liejin,CHEN Xuejun. Fluctuating differential pressure for air-water two-phase flow[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE,2002,22(3):23-27.
[11] BAI Bofeng,ZHANG Shaojun,ZHAO Liang,et al. Online recognition of the multiphase flow regime[J]. Science in China Series E:Technological Sciences,2008,51(8):1186-1194.
[12] SHABAN H,TAVOULARIS S. Identification of flow regime in vertical upward air-water pipe flow using differential pressure signals and elastic maps[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow,2014,61:62-72.
[13] ZOU Suifeng,GUO Liejin,XIE Chen. Fast recognition of global flow regime in pipeline-riser system by spatial correlation of differential pressures[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow,2017,88:222-237.
[14] SHABAN H,TAVOULARIS S. Measurement of gas and liquid flow rates in two-phase pipe flows by the application of machine learning techniques to differential pressure signals[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow,2014,67:106-117.
[15] ZHENG Xuebo,HE Denghui,YU Zhigang,et al. Error analysis of gas and liquid flow rates metering method based on differential pressure in wet gas[J]. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,2016,79:245-253.
[16] ISO. Natural gas-wet gas flow measurement in natural gas operations,PD ISO/TR 12748:2015(E)[R]. London,UK:British Standards Institution,2015.
[17] JAMES R. Metering of steam-water two-phase flow by sharp-edged orifices[J]. Process Instrumentation for Mechanical Engineers,1965,180(23):549-566.
[18] LIN Zonghu. Two-phase flow measurements with sharp-edged orifices[J]. International Journal of Multiphase Flow,1982,8(6):683-693.
[19] de LEEUW R. Liquid correction of Venturi meter readings in wet gas flow[C]//Proceedings of the 1997 North Sea Flow Measurement Workshop. London,UK:Energy Institute,1998:153-161.
[20] STEVEN R N. Wet gas metering with a horizontally mounted Venturi meter[J]. Journal of Flow Measurement and Instrumentation,2002,12(5):361-372.
[21] COLLINS A,STEVE C. Evolution of wet gas Venturi metering and wet gas correction algorithms[J]. Measurement and Control,2013,46(1):15-20.
[22] XU Ying,ZHANG Qiang,ZHANG Tao,et al. An overreading model for nonstandard Venturi meters based on H correction factor[J]. Measurement,2015,61:100-106.
[23] YUAN Chao,XU Ying,ZHANG Tao,et al. Experimental investigation of wet gas over reading in Venturi[J]. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,2015,66:63-71.
[24] HE Denghui,BAI Bofeng,XU Yong,et al. A new model for the V-cone meter in low pressure wet gas metering[J]. Measurement Science and Technology,2012,23(12):125305.1-05.9.
[25] HE Denghui,BAI Bofeng. Two-phase mass flow coefficient of V-cone throttle device[J]. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,201457:77-85.
[26] HE Denghui,BAI Bofeng. A new correlation for wet gas flow rate measurement with Venturi meter based on two-phase mass flow coefficient[J]. Measurement,2014,58:61-67.
[27] WANG Wenran,TONG Yunxian. A new method of two-phase flow measurement by orifice plate differential pressure noise[J]. Flow Measurement and Instrumentation,1995,6(4):265-270.
[28] 申国强,林宗虎. 应用动态法进行气液两相流的双参数测量[J]. 计量学报,1993,14(2):140-145. SHEN Guoqiang,LIN Zonghu. A dynamic method for dual parameter measurements of gas-liquid biphase flow[J]. Acta Metrologica Sinica,1993,14(2):140-145.
[29] GENG Yanfeng,ZHENG Jinwu,SHI Tianming,et al. Wet gas meter development based on slotted orifice couple and neural network techniques[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering,2007,15(2):281-285.
[30] HALL A,PRIDDY B,STEVEN R,et al. Horizontally installed orifice plate meter response to wet gas flows[R]. Tonsberg,Norway:North Sea Flow Measurement Workshop,2011.
[31] YUAN Chao,XU Ying,ZHANG Tao,et al. Experimental research on pressure drop of wet gas flow in Venturi[J]. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science,2016,75:183-88.
