以某卧式加工中心为研究对象,通过定义机床各部件局部坐标系间初始位置特征矩阵和初始位置误差特征矩阵,构建机床空间误差完备模型,解决传统建模方法中若干项几何误差元素缺失的问题。借助体对角线定位精度测量实验,对所建完备模型准确性进行验证,进而在此基础上提出几何误差元素实际参预度的概念及其计算方法,并由此形成基于空间误差完备模型和实际参预度的关键几何误差元素辨识新方法。分别根据计算所得实际参预度和灵敏度,对给定加工中心关键几何误差元素进行甄别。对比分析显示,相较于传统灵敏度分析,所提基于实际参预度的甄别方法具有更高的准确性。甄别结果表明,该加工中心关键几何误差元素有7项,且均与位置相关,与X轴进给相关的关键几何误差元素有4项,说明机床X轴运动组件制造精度可能存在较大缺陷。
Taking a horizontal machining center as the research object, a complete volumetric error model was established by defining the initial position and position error characteristic matrix for local coordinates of each components of machine tools, so as to solve the problems that some geometric error elements(GEE) were lost when concerning about the conventional volumetric error modeling methodology. The proposed complete volumetric model was experimentally validated by measuring the volumetric diagonal positioning errors. The concept, as well as the calculation approaches, of GEEs actual contribution factors(ACF) were presented on the basis of the complete volumetric error model. A novel methodology for identifying the crucial GEEs was furtherly formulated with the help of complete volumetric error model and ACF. Based on the calculated ACFs or sensitivities, the crucial GEEs of the given machining center were respectively identified. The comparative analyses show that the proposed identification methodology, fundamental of which is the concept of ACF, is more accurate and effective than that based on traditional sensitivities analyses. The identified results indicate that there are 7 crucial GEEs for the studied machining center, which are all position-dependent. In particular, 4 elements of the crucial GEEs are related with feeding motions in X-axis, which suggests that the machine tool movable components in X-axis may have massive flaws affected the manufacturing accuracy.
[1] CONG D C, CHINH B B, JOOHO H. Volumetric Error Model for Multi-axis Machine Tools[J]. Procedia Manufacturing,2015,1:1-11.
[2] VAHEBI M, AREZOO B. Accuracy Improvement of Volumetric Error Modeling in CNC Machine Tools[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2018, 95(5/8):2243-2257.
[3] XIANG Sitong, YANG Jianguo, FAN Kaiguo, et al. Multi-machine Tools Volumetric Error Generalized Modeling and Ethernet-based Compensation Technique[J]. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part B:Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 2016, 230(5):202-211.
[4] LEE R S, LIN Y H. Applying Bidirectional Kinematics to Assembly Error Analysis for Five-axis Machine Tools with General Orthogonal Configuration[J]. International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2012, 62(9/12):1261-1272.
[5] FUJISHIMA M, NARIMATSU K, IRINO N, et al. Thermal Displacement Reduction and Compensation of a Turning Center[J]. CIRP Journal of Manufacturing Science and Technology, 2018:S1755581718300166.
[6] 程强,刘广博,刘志峰,等. 基于敏感度分析的机床关键性几何误差源识别方法[J]. 机械工程学报,2012,48(7):171-179. CHENG Qiang, LIU Guangbo, LIU Zhifeng, et al. An Identification Approach for Key Geometric Error Sources of Machine Tool Based on Sensitivity Analysis[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2012, 48(7):171-179.
[7] 范晋伟,吕琦.复合数控机床几何误差建模及灵敏度分析[J]. 制造技术与机床,2017(3):69-73. FAN Jinwei, LUY Qi. Geometric Error Modeling and Sensitivity Analysis of Compound CNC Machine Tools[J]. Manufacturing Technology & Machine Tool, 2017(3):69-73.
[8] YANG Jixiang, DING Han. A New Position Independent Geometric Errors Identification Model of Five-axis Serial Machine Tools Based on Differential Motion Matrices[J]. International Journal of Machine Tools & Manufacture, 2016, 104:68-77.
[9] CHENG Qiang, WU Can, GU Peihua, et al. An Analysis Methodology for Stochastic Characteristic of Volumetric Error in Multiaxis CNC Machine Tool[J]. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2013(3):1-12.
[10] ZHANG Yi, YANG Jianguo, XIANG Sitong, et al. Volumetric Error Modeling and Compensation Considering Thermal Effect on Five-axis Machine Tools[J]. Proceedings of Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part C:Journal of Mechanical Engineering Science, 2013, 227(5):1102-1115.
[11] 范晋伟,邢亚兰,郗艳梅,等. 三坐标数控机床误差建模与补偿的实验研究[J]. 机械设计与制造,2008(9):150-152. FAN Jinwei, XING Yalan, XI Yanmei, et al. Investigation of Error Modeling and Error Compensation of 3-axis NC Machine[J]. Mechanical Design & Manufacture, 2008(9):150-152.
[12] 刘延柱,潘振宽,戈新生. 多体系统动力学[M]. 第2版. 北京:高等教育出版社,2014. LIU Yanzhu, PAN Zhenkuan, GE Xinsheng. Dynamics of Multibody Systems[M]. 2nd ed. Beijing:Higher Education Press, 2014.
[13] 粟时平,李圣怡,王贵林. 基于空间误差模型的加工中心几何误差辨识方法[J]. 机械工程学报,2002,38(7):121-125. SU Shiping, LI Shengyi, WANG Guilin. Geometric Error Identification Method of Machining Center Based on Volumetric Error Model[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering, 2002, 38(7):121-125.
[14] 刘又午,刘丽冰,赵小松,等. 数控机床误差补偿技术研究[J]. 中国机械工程,1998,9(12):4852-4852. LIU Youwu, LIU Libing, ZHAO Xiaosong, et al. Research on Error Compensation Technology of CNC Machine Tools[J]. China Mechanical Engineering, 1998,9(12):4852-4852.
[15] XIANG Sitong, YANG Jianguo, ZHANG Yi. Using a Double Ball Bar to Identify Position-independent Geometric Errors on the Rotary Axes of Five-axis Machine Tools[J]. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2014, 70(9/12):2071-2082.